DEEP DIVE — REVIEW ANALYSIS

AESTURA AtoCica 365 Hydrating Toner pH4.5 200ml

500 Olive Young reviews read first-hand · Olive Young rating 4.8 (2,319 reviews) · 70% gentle with no irritation · 59% soothing · 58% combination skin (Olive Young official) · a weakly acidic pH4.5 cica hydrating toner

Compiled by the Olyoung Jjintem Editorial Team

4.8

Olive Young rating (2,319 reviews)

70%

Gentle, no irritation (Olive Young)

97%

★4–5 among reviews read (500)

pH4.5

Weakly acidic 200ml hydrating toner

🧺 Snapped in-store, by usReal shelf photos we took on our own visit to an Olive Young store.

The most frequently mentioned point is hydration. Comments on hydration and moisture like 'moist without being sticky' and 'no tightness even in several layers' were the most common, at 171 reviews. Descriptions that the texture is thin but slightly more viscous than water, so the moisture doesn't evaporate quickly, recur.

Next come gentleness and a calming feel. 148 reviews say 'no irritation even when my skin is in a sensitive state,' and 93 mention 'my skin feels comfortable and calmer after applying it' (Olive Young: 70% gentle with no irritation, 59% soothing). Some say they use it as the first step of their morning routine because it's weakly acidic at pH4.5. That said, the soothing effect is users' own impressions.

Loyalty is high, with 100 holy-grail and repurchase stories about finishing several bottles. On the other hand, there are complaints that the size shrank and the twist cap became a flip cap after the reformulation (15 reviews), comments that it feels slightly greasy on oily skin, and a few reports of breakouts during use, so it's best to start with a small amount and check how your skin reacts.

These are counts taken directly only from reviews, out of the 500 read, where the expression appeared clearly (a single review can fall under several items). If anything, we undercounted rather than inflated — it's a minimum.

Olive Young official attribute metrics (based on 2,319 reviews, rating 4.8; top response per axis). These are not values we assigned — they're as tallied on Olive Young.

Expressions found in the reviews read (original tone kept, not rewritten)

1. Moist hydration — the most-mentioned pointThe most frequently mentioned point (171 reviews). Comments that it's moist without stickiness and, being slightly viscous, the hydration lasts. Descriptions that it doesn't feel heavy even when layered several times recur.
2. Gentle even when skin is sensitive148 reviews say they could apply it without irritation even when their skin was sensitive or their barrier was compromised. It lines up with Olive Young's irritation metric of 70% 'gentle with no irritation.'
3. A comfortable, calming feel93 reviews mention that skin feels comfortable and calmer after applying it (Olive Young: 59% good for soothing). Some also describe using it together with the ampoule and cream from the same AtoCica 365 line.
4. A holy-grail toner — repurchase loyalty100 repurchase stories say they've finished several bottles and it's their go-to toner. Mentions of using it as the first step of a morning routine because it's weakly acidic at pH4.5 follow.

1. Size and cap changed after the reformulation15 reviews mention that the size shrank and the twist cap became a flip cap with the reformulation. Opinions are split between those who find the flip cap convenient and those who find it inconvenient because the liquid spills.
2. Slightly shiny on oily skinSome with oily or oily-dehydrated skin say they feel oiliness or shine if they apply a lot. Advice to adjust the amount recurs.
3. Price feels on the higher sideSome mention it's somewhat pricey for the size, so many buy it during sales or value-pack promotions.
4. A few reports of breakoutsThere are a few low-rated reviews saying breakouts or something like folliculitis appeared during use. Even with cica ingredients, it may not suit every skin.
5. Based on users' own impressionsGentleness and soothing are users' own impressions and vary by person. We make no efficacy claims.

• When you're looking for a gentle daily toner you can apply to sensitized skin without irritation. Many gentleness reviews, and 70% gentle with no irritation
• When you want a hydrating toner that's moist without stickiness. Hydration comments are the most common
• When you want to start your morning routine with a weakly acidic (pH4.5) toner
• When you already use the AESTURA AtoCica 365 ampoule or cream and want to match the same line

May not suit you if: When you mainly want a wipe-off toner (used with a cotton pad). Many reviews say they use it as a pat-in toner / When you have oily skin and are sensitive to oiliness. Some say it gets shiny if you apply a lot / When you expect the pre-reformulation size and cap style unchanged

• Right after cleansing, pour it into your palm and pat it in, and on dry days layer it 2–3 times — that's the common routine in reviews
• Some advise that oily or oily-dehydrated skin should use less and apply a thin layer to reduce shine
• If the liquid spilling bothers you, a tip is to decant it into a foam or mist bottle
• When starting it, the recurring advice is to use a small amount for a few days to check how your skin reacts, and stop if breakouts appear

• Some mention it's somewhat pricey for the size, so many buy it during Olive Young sales or value-pack promotions (1+1, free gifts)
• Some reviews say the size changed after the reformulation, so the recurring advice is to check the ml listed and compare the Olive Young price and the Coupang price before buying Check the price on Coupang →

Real-user and in-store trend tally for the toner and pad category (Olive Young JJintem's own data)

See the full Toners & pads ranking →

Some links on this page are Coupang Partners affiliate links; we may earn a small commission on purchases. Some links use NAVER Shopping Connect. Commissions never affect rankings.