DEEP DIVE — REVIEW ANALYSIS

Celimax Eraser Cica BHA Blemish Toner Pad 60 pads value set (+60 pads)

496 Olive Young reviews read first-hand · Olive Young rating 4.9 (2,839 reviews, official) · 97% ★4–5 and 94% ★5 among reviews read (our own tally) · a cica BHA wipe-off pad that 'erases' dead skin and uneven texture

Compiled by the Olyoung Jjintem Editorial Team

4.9

Olive Young rating (2,839 reviews, official)

97%

Positive reviews (★4–5 of 496 read)

94%

Share of 5-star ratings (496 read)

120 pads

60-pad main + 60-pad refill set

🧺 Snapped in-store, by usReal shelf photos we took on our own visit to an Olive Young store.

The most frequently mentioned point is dead skin and uneven texture. Comments like 'the bumpy texture on my forehead went down,' 'if I wipe in the evening before bed, my skin is smooth the next day,' and 'my skin texture gets smoother' are the most common, at 216 of 496 reviews. There are also 201 impressions that wiping for a few days when tiny bumps or breakouts start to appear calms them down. That said, these are users' own impressions, and some ★3 reviews say 'I'm not sure about either the soothing or the texture improvement.'

Next, true to the 'eraser' name, is the satisfaction of wiping. In 144 reviews, people say one wipe leaves skin feeling refreshed and a lot comes off onto the pad, and yet 122 say it's gentle and low-irritation. On the other hand, 41 reviews say the BHA made it sting or feel tingly, or that scrubbing hard caused breakouts, and some people avoid using it on sensitive areas like the cheeks.

The pad's structure and set also come up often. In 99 reviews, people mention that after the renewal you can tear it in half and it's double-sided, with an embossed side and a smooth side. Opinions split between praise like 'tearing it in half makes it last longer' and the view that 'since I only use it for wiping, the old version that didn't tear apart was better.' There are 106 comments on the value of the set including a 60-pad refill, plus complaints that there's too little essence so it's drying and that there's no tweezer.

These are minimum counts based on the 496 reviews read first-hand. Exact duplicate sentences were removed from the 500 collected. These are mention counts and don't only mean people saw results (they include mentions of not noticing anything).

The Olive Young listing doesn't show attribute metrics, so we tallied the star-rating distribution of the 496 reviews read ourselves (our own tally).

Expressions found in the reviews read (original tone kept, not rewritten)

1. Smoothing dead skin and uneven texture — the most-mentioned pointThe most frequently mentioned point (216 reviews). Texture-smoothing comments like 'wipe in the evening before bed and it's smooth the next day' and 'the bumpy texture on my forehead went down' (users' own impressions; results vary by person).
2. Impressions of soothing breakouts and tiny bumpsIn 201 reviews, people say that when tiny bumps or breakouts are starting, wiping morning and evening for a few days makes them go down quickly. Some also mention that, as a cica pad, it helped reduce a hot, flushed feeling.
3. A refreshing 'wiped-clean' feel + gentleness144 reviews say one wipe leaves skin feeling refreshed, yet 122 say it's soft and low-irritation. Comparisons like 'other wipe-off toners don't feel this refreshing' recur.
4. Tear-in-half, double-sided pad + refill setIn 99 reviews, people say they tear it in half and use the embossed or smooth side depending on the situation. In 106, people praise the value of the 120-pad set including a 60-pad refill.

1. BHA irritation — stinging or tingling41 reviews say the BHA made it tingle or sting, or that scrubbing hard caused breakouts. Some people avoid using it on sensitive areas like the cheeks.
2. Little essence — drying34 complaints say there's too little essence so it's drying, or that the tub runs dry and you have to keep flipping it. Some also mention very dry skin may find it drying.
3. Tear-in-half renewal is hit-or-missMany find the new tear-in-half pad convenient, but others say 'since I use it for wiping, the old version that didn't tear apart was better' or 'it's cotton, so it doesn't split cleanly.'
4. No tweezerSome mention the set doesn't include a tweezer, so they reuse one they already have.
5. Based on users' own impressionsDead-skin and breakout comments are users' own impressions and vary by person. We make no efficacy claims.

• When your skin texture is rough from bumpy texture or dead skin on the forehead or chin. Texture-smoothing reviews are the most common
• When you want to manage tiny bumps or breakouts with a wipe-off pad as soon as they start to appear
• Oily or combination skin looking for a wipe-off pad that leaves skin feeling refreshed
• When you want a large size including a refill to use consistently

May not suit you if: Sensitive skin with a weak barrier or that easily stings with BHA / When you want a moist, essence-soaked toner-mask pad. Some say there's too little essence / Very dry skin that finds dryness after wiping uncomfortable

• A common routine is to wipe lightly along the skin's texture with the embossed side after cleansing in the evening, then tear off the smooth half and rest it briefly on breakout areas
• Some reviews say scrubbing hard can cause irritation or breakouts, so the recurring advice is to ease up and sweep gently
• Many avoid it on sensitive days or on delicate areas like the cheeks, and use it mainly on the forehead, nose, and chin where texture is uneven
• If the tub is running low on liquid, one workaround is to close the lid and leave the tub upside down for a while before using

• The main option is the 60-pad + 60-pad refill set, so the per-pad price is low — some say 'it was expensive at first, but the discounts have gotten better'
• There are reviews saying 'I bought it because Olive Young was cheapest' alongside complaints that coupon conditions didn't apply, so we recommend checking the Olive Young sale price, the Coupang price, and coupon conditions before buying Check the price on Coupang →

Real-user and in-store trend tally for the toner and pad category (Olive Young JJintem's own data)

See the full Toners & pads ranking →

Some links on this page are Coupang Partners affiliate links; we may earn a small commission on purchases. Some links use NAVER Shopping Connect. Commissions never affect rankings.