DEEP DIVE — REVIEW ANALYSIS

KISSME Long & Curl Mascara + Speedy Mascara Remover

75 Korean Olive Young reviews read one by one · Official ★4.7 (6,000+ reviews) · 'No smudging' 60% · 4 mentions in our Threads tally (cleansing category)

KISSME Long & Curl Mascara + Speedy Mascara Remover product image
4.7
Official Olive Young rating (6,000+)
60%
'No smudging' (official)
75
Reviews we read one by one
4
Threads mentions (our tally)
The KISSME mascara is 'the waterproof whose curl never dies' — and its dedicated remover is the partner that melts it off. The set is the formula. Across 75 Korean Olive Young reviews, 'the curl holds all day' leads at 15 mentions, and zero smudging (10) matches the official 'no smudging 60%' stat. What makes this product special is removal — the waterproof is so strong that regular cleansers struggle (6 mentions), which is why 'the dedicated remover melts it right off' (12) became the established set-buying formula. It's also why our Threads tally lists the remover itself — not the mascara — with 4 mentions in the cleansing category. A years-deep repurchase staple (8), praised even by short, sparse lashes (5). Sources: ~75 Korean Olive Young purchase reviews read one by one (keyword counts are conservative minimums; the sample is the Long & Curl mascara page, which includes dedicated-remover set reviews) · official Olive Young displays (★4.7 · 'no smudging' 60% — total count reads 6,000+, exact digits illegible in capture) · our Threads tally (4 remover mentions, cleansing). Read & written 2026-07-28. We never republish review text, invent ratings, or make efficacy claims.
View product
01

Community summary

Sample Olive Young reviews read 75Threads mention tally 4 Total 75 Read on 2026-07-28

The center is curl — 'holds all day', 'even my straight-down lashes stay lifted till evening' lead at 15 mentions. Some skip the curler entirely (4). Zero smudging (10) matches the official 60% stat, with real-world waterproof proof — tears and summer sweat included (4).

Why this page covers the remover too: the waterproof is strong enough that regular cleansing struggles (6 mentions), so 'apply the dedicated remover, wait, rub — it melts off' (12) became the set formula. Buying mascara and remover together is the repeated pattern, and the remover alone earned 4 mentions in our Threads cleansing tally.

It's a years-deep steady-seller ('been using only this for years', 8 mentions), and short, sparse lashes report the fibers fill them in (5). The honest flip side: without the remover, residue lingers around the eyes — the main low-star complaint. Buying the set is effectively the premise, says the review consensus.

Actual counts from the 75 reviews where sentences were clearly legible — conservative minimums, never inflated.

Curl holds / no drooping 15
Remover melts it off / set buying 12
Zero smudging / no panda eyes 10
Repurchase / longtime staple 8
Won't come off without remover 6
Works on short, sparse lashes 5
Curl even without a curler 4
Survives tears & summer 4

Phrases we met in the reviews (original tone preserved)

curl holds all daystraight lashes stay liftedgoodbye panda eyesremover melts it offbuy them as a setonly this for yearscurler optionalregular cleanser won't cut it
03

Strengths reviewers kept mentioning

  1. A curl that refuses to dieTop theme (15) — the settling story of straight, droopy lashes repeats; some skip the curler entirely (4)
  2. Zero-smudge waterproofNo panda eyes (10) — matching the official 'no smudging' 60%; tear-and-summer field reports (4) as proof
  3. The set formula with its dedicated remover'Apply, wait, rub — melts off' (12); buying both together is the established pattern. The remover alone took 4 Threads mentions
  4. A years-deep repurchase stapleLong-term repurchases (8) + fibers filling short, sparse lashes (5) — a steady-seller beyond trends
04

Downsides (mentioned repeatedly)

  1. Hard to remove without the remover (the set is the premise)Regular cleansers struggle, say 6 mentions — the main low-star reason. Budget for the remover
  2. Removal adds a stepApply the remover, wait, then rub — if you want one-step cleansing, this isn't that lane
  3. Only partial official stats capturedOnly ★4.7 and 'no smudging 60%' were legible in this sample — remaining stat labels withheld until captured clearly
05

Best for

May not suit you if: Anyone wanting a single-wash cleansing routine — the remover set is the reality / Maximum-volume seekers — this one's job is curl hold and length

06

Usage tips from reviews

07

Price & buying tips

08

Compared with other Cleansing picks

Cleansing category from our Threads real-user tally (our own data)

KISSME Mascara Remover this page 4 mentions
BIODERMA Sensibio H2O Micellar Water 12 mentions · staff 4 category #1 — 4 staff picks (deep-dive available)
make p:rem Safe Me Cleansing Milk 6 mentions gentle cleansing milk — category #2
POND'S Lip & Eye Makeup Remover 4 mentions point-remover alternative — also cited for residue cleanup
Anua Cleansing Oil 4 mentions cleansing-oil lane

See the full Cleansing ranking →

09

FAQ

Q. Does the curl really hold?

'Holds all day' leads our 75-review read at 15 mentions — even straight-down lashes stay lifted till evening. A user-experience tally with individual variation.

Q. Does it smudge?

No-panda-eyes reports total 10, and the official stat reads 'no smudging' 60%. Four reviews confirm it survived tears and summer sweat.

Q. Is it really hard to remove?

Yes — regular cleansers struggle (6 mentions), the main low-star complaint. The flip side: the dedicated remover melts it off (12 mentions). The set purchase is effectively the premise.

Q. Do I have to buy the dedicated remover?

By review consensus, yes — 'melts off with the remover' (12) and 'won't come off without it' (6) appear as two sides of the same coin. Buying both together is the pattern.

Q. Will it work on short lashes?

Short, sparse lashes report the fibers fill and extend them (5 mentions), and some get curl without a curler (4) — beginner-friendly reviews included.

Q. When should I buy?

Remover-included sets cycle regularly — since you'll need the remover anyway, set timing is the rational buy.

Q. What does Threads say?

Interestingly, our Threads tally lists the remover — not the mascara — with 4 cleansing-category mentions: 'nothing else takes it off' is the remover's own fame.

Q. Where does this page's data come from?

The ★4.7 and 'no smudging 60%' are official Olive Young displays; keyword counts are our hand-tally of ~75 reviews (conservative minimums). No republished text, no invented ratings, no efficacy claims.

View product
🧳 Haul getting heavy? Seoul luggage storage, sorted →
← Back to full ranking See Cleansing ranking →
How was this ranking made?

Starting from a viral Threads post with over 1.85M views, we collected real Korean users' recommendation comments on Olive Young posts, merged different spellings of the same product, and tallied mentions, likes, and staff endorsements. No ads or sponsorships — rankings come from real recommendation data only.

Some links on this page are Coupang Partners affiliate links; we may earn a small commission on purchases. Some links use NAVER Shopping Connect. Commissions never affect rankings.